Friday, June 5, 2015

Are we missing the big picture ?

Now-a-days, making claims of working on development of affordable healthcare devices has become more of a fashion statement and is seen as an easy route to gain visibility in the society. Though it attracts heavy funding from government, it is anybody’s guess how many such devices really translate into commercially viable market ready products and actually deliver in the field.
While not questioning the novel intent of people jumping into the bandwagon of affordable device developers, one won’t be really off the mark in stating that they do not necessarily address the needs of the masses where the word “affordability” actually matters. Take for instance, getting an ultrasound / MRI scan etc done is not cheap unless it is heavily subsidized and as a result, patients seeking to get these scans done in government run setups get wait periods starting from few days to months together.
Though healthcare services are offered by private setups at rates, often beyond the paying capacity of a common man, one cannot overlook the fact that most of the high end medical equipments are imported. Not only are they expensive to procure, their spare parts and related disposable accessories, if any, are sold at premium. And hence, one is at the mercy of the whims of the foreign manufacturer, irrespective of the service provider.
The only way to break the monopoly of the foreign players is by raising the barriers to entry into the Indian market through indigenous development of similar devices with no frills attached and making them mandatory to be picked up by the government run healthcare setups. While it is easier said than done, development of high end medical devices need involvement of good dedicated people both from science and engineering background to work in parallel with the medical fraternity. Though a sophisticated functional medical device cannot be churned out within a short time, with the right intent, a good team should be able to develop the same within a given time frame and a reasonable budget. It is not too unrealistic a target for Indian scientific community to achieve, if it is seen in perspective of the achievements of scientists in Indian Space Research Organization who have proven that there is no dearth of talent in India to deal with complex scientific problems. Another successful story highlighting the Indian talent is that of development of indigenous supercomputer Param when India was denied access to the Cray supercomputers initially by the US government.
Keeping in tune with our present Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi’s “Make in India” campaign, the government should provide the right eco-system to train students and motivate them to take up research in fields where there is a requirement of certain gestation period in order to get good results. More integrated five year dual degree programs like the one offered by IIT-BHU should be introduced in various institutes. While the primary degree (BSc./BTech/BE) should be in a core field of science or engineering, the secondary degree (MSc./MTech/ME) in Biomedical engineering should constitute some core courses offered in medicine as well. It has been observed that students with a primary degree in Biomedical Engineering do not have strong foundation in any core (engineering / science) field in particular and it is the mishmash of subjects taught in such courses which make the student a jack of all trades and master of none.
While the tuition fees of such dual degree programs should be kept high to ensure the best of facilities, it should be ensured that the students after completion of such programs get immediately absorbed in government institutions for a fixed duration, something similar on the lines of short service commission offered by the forces. This would ensure that students are not left clueless about their future after the completion of the course or end up joining private firms at lucrative salaries and have jobs nothing to do with Biomedical Engineering. Raising the amount of grant in research fellowship is a welcome step in this direction.
While continuing with the present approach of inviting new project proposals, the government on its own should set targets where the specifications of the devices are well defined after consultation with the medical fraternity and subsequently the work delegated to institutes depending on their expertise. 
Facilitating smooth execution in a professional manner of high impact medical device development projects with proper audit at every step and providing the requisite support at any point of time to such projects, without allowing the ego of the people of various institutes to come into play will ensure that tax-payers’ money is well spent to make healthcare “affordable” in true sense.

Saturday, April 17, 2010

What drives medical device development ?

There is a popular saying that “Necessity is the mother of invention” but it doesn’t seem to hold water in the “Medical Technology” domain. In a country like India where the healthcare setup is failing, one can easily identify substantial number of “Needs” which can be addressed through technology developed using the currently available infrastructure. Then why is it so that there is a drought of indigenously developed medical devices to address these “Needs”.
The diagram of a funnel is often cited to depict the various steps involved in filtration of “Needs-Identified” in order to successfully launch a medical device in the market. But then there has to be a driving force for the filtration to take place and a closer look will reveal that the driving force is fuelled mainly by the gravity of “Greed” rather than that of “Need”.
It is well known that the so-called filtration process gets influenced by the ability of the device manufacturer to translate the idea into a profitable venture, unless one is into philanthropy. Surely, no identified “Needs” are less important; otherwise it wouldn’t have caught one’s eye at the first place. However, the gravity of the “Need” is determined by the “Return of Investment” involved in addressing the “Need” in question.
Numerous technologies have been developed by the academia through research grants from government but there have been no takers for obvious reasons. The problem is universal as someone has rightly stated about the recently passed US Healthcare Reform Bill that no number of reforms would succeed in improving the healthcare scenario unless people stop being greedy.

Friday, April 16, 2010

Licensing Strategy: A conflict of interest

In the “Healthcare Technology” domain, introspection of the process of “Technology Transfer” from academia to industry would reveal a conflict of interest between the two respective parties. In order to prevent the monopoly of a single player in the market, usually the academia insists on “Non-Exclusive Licensing” of the medical technology developed utilizing government funds. And it quite often happens that due to lack of healthy competition, instead of putting in efforts for further refinement of the technology, the licensee would try to command a price in the market, eventually making it unaffordable for the common man to reap the benefits of technology coming out of government funded research.
Though the government’s policy is clearly aimed at protecting the interests of common man, this is viewed as a losing proposition by the industry because a potential licensee would never like to go for a “Non-Exclusive Licensing” of the medical technology for obvious reasons. No firm would like to have a competitor possessing the same technology in the market. Also, it is quite possible that if the new technology is perceived as a threat to the market of an existing product, then the technology owner of the existing product would try to seek an “Exclusive License” of the technology in question and then kill it by not taking it to the market.
This turf-war between the licensee and the licensor makes the industry go on back-foot while scouting for new technology churned out by the academia and ultimately, it is the tax-payer’s money which gets wasted when the technology developed does not move from the lab to market.
Instead of waiting for the industry to come forward, the government should take pro-active steps in harnessing the benefits of the technology developed. In this regard, the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare (MoHFW) can take a cue from the Ministry of Defence (MoD) where all the critical requirements of the forces are met by public sector undertakings (PSU) like BEL, BDL etc. Something on similar lines should be worked out where medical technology developed by academia through public funding, be taken up for translation into a marketable product by government run bodies. Marketing of these products should not be a problem as it can be made mandatory for the government run hospitals to be equipped with such indigenously developed products. Fortunately, steps in this direction have been initiated as demonstrated in the case of the technology for a “Syringe Infusion Pump” developed recently in All India Institute of Medical Sciences [AIIMS, New Delhi]. The related technology development in AIIMS was funded by the Ministry of Information Technology and later transferred to West Bengal Electronics [WEBEL] for further refinement and commercialization. It is envisaged that such initiatives may also generate new jobs indirectly.

Friday, January 29, 2010

Tackling apathy towards rural healthcare

The government has set up rural healthcare centres but they have failed to deliver because of lack of trained medical personnel and the reluctance of the undergraduate doctors to visit the rural areas as a part of their internship in their MBBS curricula.
To address this issue, the government is planning to award extra credits to the interns for the rural visits or enable them to graduate on a fast track mode. However, this process will not be helpful in long run as not many doctors are really motivated to serve in the rural areas and a job done half-heartedly does not really bring the benefits expected out of this program. Also, it is obvious that people used to city-bred life find it difficult to adjust to the rural setup and that too where there are no accompanied monetary gains.
A more logical step would be to tackle this problem at village level. As a part of the National Rural Health Mission (NRHM), one should visit the schools in rural areas and through lucid lectures / presentation, explain to the students as to how engineers and doctors can work together to provide a proper healthcare setup to their village. Then through a screening process testing their aptitude and academic performance, a few selected students should be groomed to take up medicine / engineering through scholarship in institutes of repute. Of course, proper mechanism needs to be put in place to ensure that the selected students do not drop out from the course mid-way and on completion of their courses / training, should go back to their respective villages to help run the healthcare centres already setup by the government.
It is envisaged that such a program would churn out trained people who would be genuinely concerned about the welfare of their village and hence, address the concerns of their community in a more efficient manner.

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Concept of "Virtual Incubator"

It has been often found that people joining the government funded projects on contractual basis are not really motivated to work for the project, for the simple reason that they use it as a stop-gap arrangement to prepare for competitive examinations like IAS etc / to go abroad for higher studies / to use it as a source of income till a job of their choice is found. There is no sense of ownership which can keep the employees engaged for productive output. Also, as the project closure date approaches, being on contractual appointment, the project employees stop taking interest in their work and get busy hunting for new job opportunities.
Keeping in view the above scenario, it is proposed that each project funded by the government, be operated as a micro-enterprise incubated virtually in the “Scientific Establishment” and after the project tenure is over, the contractual employees working in that particular project be allowed to take the project forward as a spin-off, with the “Scientific Establishment” having a stake in that. This will not only make the contractual employees work as a team for the whole project duration but also motivate them to put in their best efforts to successfully commercialize the technology developed in the project.
While the researchers (scientists, engineers, professors) working in the “Scientific Establishments” have been empowered to claim an equity stake in such “Scientific Enterprises” during the course of their professional engagement with their parent organizations, the same may be extended to the contractual staff employed in the projects. This concept of “Virtual Incubator” would provide a better focus to the work done in the projects.

Friday, June 19, 2009

Technology to structure development

In a developing country like India, education, health and agriculture sectors have to work as brothers in arms to make an effective impact on the economy.
From the health point of view, since the majority of the Indian population is based in rural areas, the Government of India has the National Rural Health Mission (NRHM) in place to help increase the outreach of the healthcare delivery systems. Assuming that this mission is a success, one would expect the mortality rate to go down. Consequently, there would be not only an increase in the longevity of the population but also a steady growth of the population. As far as population is concerned, its growth has to be handled in such a manner that there are no deaths due to starvation whereas birth control measures should not lead to a dearth of “young working” population. So the two issues which come into forefront are that of imparting education to the young population and availability of food to feed the population.
There is no point in having a large uneducated population as they cannot be gainfully employed and unemployment is one of the key reasons for civil unrest. Also, not everyone is cut out for every sort of work. To maximize productivity, one needs to impart the right kind of education according to the capability of the person. For minimum level of education, the Government of India has launched the Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan and the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (NREGS) to provide employment which is a not a self-sustainable model in the long run.
Availability of a “balanced diet” for the population is a big challenge for the Government. The National Food Security Mission (NSFM) had been setup but merely, providing food for survival is not sufficient, as it is a “balanced diet” which keeps a man healthy enough to be productive at work. With the existing Public Distribution Systems (PDS) for food and various schemes like mid-day meal for school going children and subsidized food for people living below poverty line (BPL), the government has not been really successful in achieving its goals due to rampant corruption prevailing in the country and lack of proper implementation of these schemes as they had been used as mere rhetoric for garnering votes.
In such a scenario, it is technology which can play a significant role in interweaving all the three sectors to have a synergetic effect. Merely having the latest technology is not the solution as one needs to innovate to make them adaptable for the ground users. But then social acceptance of such technologies is easier said than done in a country like India which has such a diverse population. One of the ways to achieve this is to tie-up technology companies with organizations like National Innovation Foundation (NIF) who scout around for innovative technologies at grass-root level. While business is the main driving force for the technology companies to innovate, the technologies developed at grass-root level are borne more out of necessity and have a local contextual outlook. It is the mating of the two ideologies which can together address the three sectors (health, education & agriculture) effectively as it has been found time and again that it is the user or the ultimate beneficiary who can provide the best solution or inputs to overcome the hurdles to their path of development.

Sunday, February 8, 2009

Low cost medical device

It has been observed that often people tend to claim that the medical devices developed by them are cheaper as compared to the imported ones. One needs to look into these claims with a pinch of salt before up-scaling them for commercialization. Development of a genuine low cost medical device is ultimately all about innovation and requires lot of creative and technical thinking.
In India, sufficient technical and infrastructural capability is present to replicate the functionalities of some of the imported machines. But the machines can’t be really claimed to be low cost. Often during comparisons, people forget that the expenses involved in manufacturing and marketing a device requires lot of investment and all these get added up to the cost of the machine in the market and in business, the aim is to earn revenue unless one is into philanthropy.
If one strips down all these additional expenses, then one would find in most of the cases that the cost of the imported machine is controlled by the local market prices of the components. This can be appreciated from a simple example. Suppose, a machine designed in India uses standard UL approved components. If two such machines are built with one set of components bought from the US market and the other set bought from the Chinese market, one would find that though there won’t be any difference in functionality / quality of the two machines, both being built from UL approved components, the one made from the US components would be more expensive, simply because the Chinese components are cheaper. So, technically speaking, the device is not really low cost compared to its imported counterpart on a level playing field.

Sunday, July 20, 2008

Technology Forecasting: Key to Valuation

Some of the commonly used methodologies for valuation of intellectual property (IP) are Cost-based method (principle of substitution), Income-based method (discounted cash flow) and Market-based method (price of comparable asset in market). Though the methodologies appear pretty straight forward, the results can go haywire unless the valuations are done keeping in view the technology market dynamics. It is well known that the same valuation method cannot be flatly applied in all cases and hence one arrives at a range of figures when different methods are applied.
While a seller would negotiate to get the maximum value of an IP, a buyer would negotiate to get the same IP at the minimum possible value. Though the perspective from which valuation of IP is done changes with the purpose of valuation, it is the ability to do “Technology Forecasting” where the thought processes of the buyer and the seller converge.
While a buyer may end up paying a heavy price for an IP which might face obsolescence due to competing technology or government policies, a seller may end up losing an IP at low price, in case he fails to see the promise in the related technology in near future. Thus the exercise of valuation needs the involvement of people who have hands-on experience in the related industry as they are the best judge to see the pros and cons of implementing a particular concept in view of a changing technology landscape which can drastically affect the value of an IP.
In fact, “Technology Forecasting” by domain experts is one of the key determinants in the valuation of intellectual property which can make or break the fortune of a company.

Monday, June 30, 2008

Ideas for innovators

It has been lately observed that some of the so called innovators knowingly or unknowingly have tried to claim credit for products whose concepts have already been patented. This practice should be strictly discouraged as it is unethical, amounting to infringement of patents and stymies creativity.
Leaving aside the unscrupulous elements who deliberately take this path, the remaining innovators constitute mostly of those who are not aware of the concept of patents and this is not surprising, considering the fact that the level of IP awareness is still low in India. These people should be made to realize the fact that mere absence of a product in the market does not imply that the idea had not been conceived before or the “proof-of-concept” did not exist before. The reason for absence of the product could have been that at that time, the market was not ready for such a product or the manufacturing (technical / cost) of the product did not allow commercialization to be a profitable exercise.
So while the innovators cannot claim for novelty in their ideas, they should be given due credit for converting these ideas into products which can be made available at an affordable price. In fact, that is what innovation is all about and is the need of the hour as many good ideas die in the “Valley-of-Death” while being taken from lab to market.
The government, while providing financial or technical support for commercialization of patents, should also introduce schemes to encourage innovators develop products on the basis of concepts picked up from expired patents or patents which have not been filed in India as this would give one the “Freedom-to-Operate” without the fear of patent infringement in India but of course, with due acknowledgement.

Saturday, June 28, 2008

Process patent in healthcare

In India, one cannot patent any process for prophylactic [therapeutic / diagnostic] treatment of human being. This law not only promotes healthy competition among the players in the healthcare industry, it pushes down the cost of healthcare, in the process making it affordable for the masses.
While this law is intended to protect the interests of the masses in general, one needs to look at it from the perspective of the organizations involved in the development of such processes.
There exists lot of government funded institutions where considerable amount of effort, money and time is being spent in the research and development of such processes but the patents for the same have to be filed abroad as these processes are not patentable in India. This implies that anybody in India can pick up that idea and practice it as he / she has the “Freedom-to-Operate” in India. Operating on similar lines, even an Indian subsidiary of a multinational can also create an entry barrier to the local players through its strong market standing and technical strength. So, in order to reap the benefits of a foreign patent, one should enforce it.
It is true that litigation is not only a risky but an expensive and long drawn affair. Hence, only when the stakes are high and the organizations have a strong defense and finance to sustain such activities, do they challenge patent infringements. Seen from that perspective, the government funded research institutions are better placed compared to individual inventors and if they do not assert their rights over their intellectual property, then filing of foreign patents becomes a futile exercise.
Since the government funded research institutions have lot of foreign patents, the government should setup a dedicated body to act as a watchdog for the enforcement of such patents. This will allow the government to capitalize on the foreign patents by forcing the infringers to negotiate for license / sale of the patents. After all, it is an investment of the tax payer’s money made by the government and the government should ensure that they get proper return on investment.

Wednesday, June 11, 2008

"Earnest Money" in commercialization of IP

It has been often observed that the departments handling the Intellectual Property (IP) of research institutes do not have adequate manpower / expertise to commercialize the IP. Consequently, they either post the details of the IP on the web or engage consultancy firms to market them. While the former is an open ended exercise with no guarantee of the IP being picked up, the latter also becomes a half-hearted exercise as the consultancy firms do not get paid for the ground-work done till there is a successful transaction. While the consultancy firms argue that they need to be paid for the expenses incurred irrespective of a successful transaction, the research institutes counter that argument by stating that there is no foolproof method to check the claims for the money spent by the consultancy firms for undertaking this exercise. Ultimately, it is the research institute which suffers as with passing days, the value as well as the life of the IP keeps going down.
A business model is proposed where the research institute stands to benefit from the IP till its actual commercialization takes place. Whenever a consultancy firm is engaged for the commercialization activity, it should be asked to deposit a fixed amount of money in lump-sum to the research institute which will be held for the period allocated to the consultancy firm to evaluate / commercialize the IP. During that period, the deposited money could be invested by the research institute in any instrument which will give returns in a very short period. Once the allocated period is over, the research institute may return the principal amount (initial deposit) back to the consultancy firm irrespective of whether it has been able to successfully commercialize the assigned IP.
This process would not only help the research institute in capitalizing on the exclusivity period given to the consultancy firm, it would also ensure that the non-committed consultancy firms get filtered out who would otherwise waste the exclusivity given, indirectly devaluing the IP.

Wednesday, June 4, 2008

Capitalizing on Institutional IP

Significant amount of funding is spent for the research work taken up in the universities and technologies developed are patented with the intention of getting revenue through licensing or sale of related Intellectual Property (IP).

But it has been observed that the academia has not been able to capitalize on the generated IP. The reason quoted quite often for this failure is that there exists a disconnect between the academia and industry, leading to filing of patents for technologies which have no real commercial value but has been done with the intention of justifying the expenditures or just improving the inventor’s credentials. The other reason could be that the academia is not well equipped to properly valuate the generated IP and market it as a package to attract buyers / licensees.

Though the latter reason sounds more plausible, there is another important reason which seems to have been overlooked and that is lack of enforcement of IP rights. Generation of revenue from patents is done by following a “Carrot & Stick” policy. In case of former, it is assumed that the patents would be of interest to various parties and hence revenue would be generated by sale / licensing of the IP to the interested parties. This aspect is already being addressed.

But in case of latter, it is basically identifying potential infringers of the patents and bringing them to the negotiating table for suitable payments depending on the extent of exploitation of the patent. While the academia puts up the details of their IP on the web in order to draw the attention of potential buyers / licensees, in the process, it inadvertently exposes the ideas to outside world where it is very much possible that unscrupulous elements may as well opt to copy the ideas and use them for their own business purpose without giving due acknowledgement to the inventors in the form of payment / license fee. It is this aspect which academia seems to have ignored, probably due to lack of time or suitable official machinery.

If the academia becomes pro-active in asserting their IP rights, it is envisaged that the generated IP would give more returns on investment.

Wednesday, May 28, 2008

Health Insurance

Though there exists many agencies offering health insurance, there are not many takers for them. One reason could be that in case of health insurance, the premium paid is not of any use unless the insured person gets hospitalised and his claims satisfy the terms and conditions of the insuring agency. Also, the insurance schemes providing better coverage demand a higher premium which itself acts like a deterrent. The other plausible reason could be that people do not see health insurance as an instrument for investment since there are no returns involved.
Now-a-days, people have become health conscious. Sensing that feeling, health gyms have started mushrooming in the city. However, the clientele has remained restricted to a particular strata of people who can afford the steep membership / subscription charges.
With technological advancement, setting up of health gyms having sophisticated exercise equipments, has become relatively easy and affordable to be taken up as a line of business. A business model is proposed where the agencies offering health insurance can tie up with gyms maintaining certain minimum standards, in the process benefiting both the parties.
The insurance agency can offer health insurance policies at a lower premium to people who subscribe to the gyms tied up with that particular agency. The gym owner as well has to lower the membership / subscription charges of his facility to make it affordable for a larger group of people while trying to recover the reduced margins through increase in the number of memberships. Once the insured person buys a policy, he / she would certainly take out time to utilize the services of the gym for which he / she is paying as a part of the policy conditions, in the process paying attention to his / her health.
While the usage of a health gym as a part of this insurance package does not guarantee that the insured persons would not fall sick, under proper guidance, it would definitely improve the quality of health leading to less number of insurance claims as these people would be less susceptible to lifestyle disorders like obesity, diabetes, hyper-tension; a foundation for further complications.
It is envisaged that in such a scenario, the gym owner, the insuring agency and the insured, all the three stand to benefit from technology.